Who is Everton’s greatest player of the Premier League era?
We recently published a duel piece on who is Everton’s greatest ever player, and while the piece featured a large number of heroes, a lot of them were before the Premier League began.
For the younger generation, you weren’t able to watch many of the older giants, but there is still a modern question to ask – who is the greatest Everton player of the Premier League era?
So, while we are on international break, and the Toffees are away from the action, we thought we’d take another look into the club’s best ever players, this time with a focus on the Premier League.
We’ve put a number of contenders up against each other and all you need to do is vote for your preferred pick to find out who should be crowned the best.
You ultimately voted for .
Seamus Coleman
Gary Speed
Tim Cahill
Dave Watson
Steven Pienaar
Thomas Gravesen
Leighton Baines
Joleon Lescott
Kevin Campbell
Wayne Rooney
Romelu Lukaku
Lee Carsley
Andrei Kanchelskis
Mikel Arteta
Tim Howard
Phil Jagielka
Duncan Ferguson
Marouane Fellaini
Neville Southall
Leaderboard
Tim Cahill | 86% |
Neville Southall | 81% |
Leighton Baines | 69% |
Mikel Arteta | 69% |
Duncan Ferguson | 62% |
Romelu Lukaku | 51% |
Wayne Rooney | 43% |
Andrei Kanchelskis | 39% |
Seamus Coleman | 32% |
Tim Howard | 31% |
Phil Jagielka | 21% |
Gary Speed | 20% |
Steven Pienaar | 19% |
Kevin Campbell | 18% |
Thomas Gravesen | 11% |
Dave Watson | 10% |
Joleon Lescott | 6% |
Lee Carsley | 6% |
Marouane Fellaini | 6% |